Thursday, July 11, 2013

Learning From K9 Nose Work® NACSW™ National Invitational Video Part 1

Okay, I received a flash drive in the mail with some video of Muriel & me doing our searches at the National Invitational (woo hoo, Christmas came early this year!). We're going to look at a number of the searches using the Coach's Eye app and see how much we might learn from them. Some of you may not know much about the National Invitational - what the location was like, how each day flowed, what it was like to be a competitor sitting in shade on the backside of a building all day waiting to search and wondering where everyone was! Here are some answers: the location was industrial, each day had a morning and afternoon and we split into running orders of six teams each for the searches, the backside of the building was not too hot, and we had food, chairs, and each other's company to prevent us from going sniff crazy! That covers the summary. On to the video! I aim to keep this post lean and mean like a 2 minute, 6 hide warehouse search!



The Moat - The first search of day one of the National Invitational was a 3 minute, 5 hide mixed element search with forklifts and tires, a stand with a vice clamp, a working table, and other miscellany. It was a cluttered area with lots of tight spots for handling.



What made this search area difficult was the wind blowing across the length of the area and causing dogs to chase a little and overlook at least 1 hide (no dog found all 5). The hide overlooked by most dogs was on a stand with a vice clamp. This was between the table and one of the vehicles, and near a hide on a utility pole. Muriel & I ducked under the table to get to the back of the search area and passed right by the stand without a twitch of the nose from Muriel.

Again, this search could have been a bit different for us if we had handled the blowing odor situation better. We spent the lion's share of our time trying to work out odor on a forklift (see video below) that we never end up finding... I should say, Muriel did find the odor, she just didn't take off one of her shoes and throw it at me to tell me so.



As for the hide on the vice clamp stand, this might have been a matter of handler strategy - make sure to cover ground in many different ways, and make sure your dog is in a position to actually search that ground. This means finessing things so you guide your dog to an area, but then permit him to take control and search it. Not an easy task. I imagine this strategy would have resulted in a mess of tangled leash or the funky dance of "You go first." "No. You go first." "I'm not walking through that pinched space with that thing above my head. No thanks."

When you practice this kind of search scenario, start out with an easily navigable area and work your way to the pinched space with a thing above your dog's head (just make sure the thing can't fall on your dog's head). Even simple set-ups with tables, chairs, and household stuff to clutter the area can really help the two of you learn to navigate awkward search environments.


The Lily Pad - This search was our second of day one and it consisted of two side by side areas within a large 3-sided covered storage area. The search times were brief (3 minutes and 2 minutes), and there were 3 hides in one area and 4 in another. Forgive me, but I may not get exact details for each search area correct, but that's very much what competing in the National Invitational was like, hard to correctly remember the details during and after each search.

Search Area 1: We're going to focus on two things in this search, first is the dog that can't quite commit to the hide, and second is the handler that can't commit to the dog's signals. In the video, Muriel is pretty clear on where she wants to work, but she is not content to alert to a source (she can't reach it - not even close). I let her work for an extended period of time, but I'm not confident enough in what I'm seeing to call alert.



We waste a lot of time being discontent and unconfident. The nearby hide on the other side of the stacked wood could have been causing trouble with the decision making on the high hide. Had Muriel been guided away from the area, found the more accessible hide, and then went back to work the high hide, she might have made a clearer decision.

This is one of many cluttered and busy areas we searched, and it's worth pointing out that the very strong desire to let your dog work longer because the area seems busier is not necessarily a good strategy. If your dog struggles to lock down a hide in 15-30 seconds, move on. You can always go back.

Search Area 2: The learning experience that was search area 1 had not quite sunk in, but I was more prepared to call alert sooner if she gave me similar behavior to the high hide in search area 1. Time once again got the better of us here. We found two hides and got caught up working blowing odor to eat up the remainder of our time.



A good strategy for me & Muriel might have been shorter leash length and a little less freedom to roam. A few times she got caught up between odors or by blowing/pooling odor. For some reason, this is a hard scenario for our team to recognize and work through. Slowing things down might make it clearer for both team members when blowing/pooling odor is leading nowhere, when two odors are converging, etc. On the other hand, sometimes an odor problem needs to be solved by getting further away from the source and finding the edge of the scent plume, so, strategize with caution!



Large Warehouse Interior - A large area search with 6 minutes to find an unknown number of hides. The real challenge of this area was the high hide in the stack of pallets. Although, a number of dogs breezed by a hide at the outside corner of one of the rows of shrink-wrapped material - handlers were told to be careful in that area because of some open boxes of solar panels on shelving just a few feet away from the hide. Not sure if handler preconceptions and concerns had anything to do with dogs being less successful on that hide.

This search was about covering ground and staying out of the dog's way, as well as dealing with close convergence involving a very high inaccessible hide. Once again, troubles abounded because of blowing/pooling odor. A huge exhaust fan cooling system was running overhead while we searched, and, I believe a cargo bay door was open beyond the search area. Who knows exactly what was happening to the odor but the dogs!

Muriel had no trouble finding the threshold hide, the medium height hide in the wooden cargo box, the hide near the solar panels, and a hide in between two rows of shrink-wrapped material. I think we missed a hide on the building wall deep in the corner of the search area (or we didn't), and I missed the high pallet hide. That makes for a total of 6 hides in the area. The amount of time we spent trying to work out the high pallet hide was maddening! In the end, Muriel got frustrated and went to the wooden cargo box, sniffed the bottom corner opposite the hide and alerted. I knew it couldn't be right, but the two of us were desperate for some validation of our efforts at that point, so I called it. Nope. False call. Lose a half point.





Small Warehouse Vehicles - A traditional vehicle element search with the option to go off-leash. There were three vehicles and an unknown number of hides to find in 2 minutes. I chose to run Muriel off-leash and it worked out nicely for us. Because of the focus on vehicles I was much more able to read her signals and guide her to areas I wanted her to search, as compared to the more cluttered environments of the mixed element searches. Unlike the forklifts in The Moat, these vehicles were passenger cars (a minivan, SUV, and a 4-door sedan), and the configuration and hide placements were not really causing difficult convergence of the odors or blowing/pooling odor. This was more of a speed test to see if the team can stay on task and work efficiently.

This video contains some decent searching, but not the teachable moments contained in some of the other videos. I'll focus on the hide on the front of the SUV in the bumper to the left of the driver's side fog lamp. Muriel showed interest early on indicating she wanted to search towards the front of the SUV, but she turned off fast and worked problem. When she made her way to the front of the SUV she caught odor early, but wasn't quite there. I can't stress the usefulness of sourcing exercises and lingering odor exercises. I read Muriel correctly, but I'd prefer she work her way to source without needing to check in and test my handling skills!





Next week we'll continue the video analysis (and possibly the week after, too). Hopefully, it helps to see searches in action and hear some of a handler's inner monologue, as well as some post search reflecting.


Happy Sniffing!

32 comments:

  1. Jeff,

    I really want to watch these videos, but they come up as Private when I go to view them. Please fix!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for catching that, Brian. I checked all the videos on the blog after posting and they worked - of course, because I have access to view them in the private setting! I keep most videos private and didn't realize that had become my default.

    Hope you check back and view the videos.

    Happy Sniffing!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think we should get "30 Second Club" badges for losing our brains when we hear those dreaded words. :-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Agreed! As many times as I've ran back to an area I thought would pay off when I got that thirty second warning, I could probably be chairperson of the club.

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete
  4. Awesome! Thank you so much for sharing your videos. I will be watching them several times.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Glad they have some usefulness! Please thank the NACSW, too, for giving us permission to share the videos.

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete
  5. Thanks for fixing that. My wife and I really enjoyed watching those tonight. The bits about converging odors from the different hides was educational and it was nice to see footage of an actual working dog at the Invitational.

    Keep up the good work!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Agreed-very educational. I've bookmarked this article and will refer to the videos fairly often, I'm sure!

      Delete
    2. Thanks, Brian. Glad you & your wife found the videos useful. There are more to come!

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete
  6. Thanks so much Jeff for sharing your videos, your knowledge and your gorgeous girl.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're welcome, you're welcome, and Muriel says she's blushing beneath her fur!

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete
  7. Fabulous commentary. Thanks for sharing. I only hope I can remember it all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks! I think the commentary feature of Coach's Eye is awesome. I'd actually love to have one of the founders or another CNWI analyze one of the upcoming videos.

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete
  8. I had seen a few pix of the Invitational search areas, but oh-so-cool to see Muriel actually working them! Your commentary (plus your magic red pen!) were really helpful as you pointed out where the actual hides were, the air flow, convergence, how she was working odor, etc.

    Doubt we would have found many hides in those huge areas in 100+ degree heat, but watching these videos sure made me wish my pup and I had been there too!!

    Thanks, and please keep this stuff coming!!!!!
    Gretchen with Amica

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Amica would have done great. The heat was well managed by handlers and event organizers, so not as much of a factor as one would expect. The real challenge - as always - was overcoming handling blunders!

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete
  9. Really terrific video and the commentary is very informative. You both did wonderfully and I appreciate the opportunity to learn from your experiences. Thanks so much for sharing it.
    Liane and Ms. Kara

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thank You Jeff for sharing these videos! I am thrilled beyond belief! I have been dying to hear something from the competitors about the National Invitational. I love that you narrated and marked the videos, so we can see where the hides are . So excellent! I know I will be watching these over and over again!

    Marsha Fuzia and Walker

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Marsha!

      I hope you enjoy the rest of the videos just as much - there some great searches yet to come.

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete
    2. Hi Jeff,

      What would have been an acceptable indication to the judge for those high, inaccessible hides on the lumber and the pallets?

      Thanks,

      Marsha and Walker

      Delete
  11. Hi Jeff, we have never met, but I want to thank you for your great blog--I have learned so much from your clear and insightful writing. And this is one of the best yet. I know this must have taken a huge amount of time, so please know that it is so appreciated! Hope to meet you (and Muriel) sometime, Mia (and Boston)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Mia! Glad you enjoy the blog. This post did take a bit of time to put together, but it's always worth the effort when people get something out of it.

      Hope we can meet you & Boston sometime, as well.

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete
  12. Jeff - Thanks so much for sharing these videos with us. Love the play-by-play of the action and color commentary! Looking forward to seeing more.

    Kim with Nina and Melvim

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Kim! Hope to see you, Melvin & Nina next month.

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete
  13. Thanks for sharing! I have learned so much from your searches. I will be looking at things from a different perspective now!

    Heather

    ReplyDelete
  14. Jeff,

    What would have been an acceptable indication to the judge for the two high, inaccessible hides? Muriel had her front feet on the lumber stack and was looking straight up at the hide......even though it was several feet above her head. If you had called alert at that point...would the judge
    have said "yes"?

    Thanks for sharing,

    Marsha & Walker

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Marsha,

      Typically, what a judge looks for with a high inaccessible hide like the one in the stack of lumber is for the dog to show recognition of the odor in the general area that the source is located, and for the handler to call alert based on reading the dog's behavior.

      Luther, the judge for the search you refer to, said to me that Muriel showed me where the hide was four times (each time she sniffed on the lumber below the source of the hide and trailed up). When I finally called it, it was not clear to him that I read her behavior correctly. I called alert when she was to the right of the source and searching a different stack of lumber.

      Every search and every hide will call for it's own parameters regarding what a dog must do to find source odor and what a handler must observe and base his call on, but in general, the judge has a clear understanding of how the odor is moving and available to the dog, what the dog looks like when it has caught the odor and is trying to get to the source, and what the handler is observing when he calls alert.

      I hope this helps a little. The best way to wrap your head around acceptable calls for inaccessible hides is to see lots of these types of searches play out with many dogs and gain understanding of what the dogs are capable of in these searches and what the handlers should be able to observe. This is why judges for the sport usually come from the professional detection world; their experience makes them able to judge searches with an understanding of all the factors that may affect how the dog works, instead of just being told the dog has to do 'x' and handler has to do 'y' for it to be a correct call.

      Thanks for asking questions and taking an interest.

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete
  15. Thanks Jeff,

    That makes a lot of sense and is very helpful. I'm sure you know how valuable it is for all of us out here training and trialing to be able to watch these videos. Will any of the videos of the other teams that competed at the National be posted to your blog?

    Thank you again and hope to meet you & Muriel some day.

    Take care,

    Marsha & Walker

    ReplyDelete
  16. Great! Glad I could help.

    The other competitors are welcome to share their videos through the blog. While I author the majority of the posts to the blog, it is intended to feature guest bloggers as well - and we have had some - so readers can enjoy other voices and perspectives through the blog.

    I also thought it might be fun to hear commentary on these videos from one of the founders or one of the judges. The biggest hurdle to any of the above happening is time commitment. Many of the competitors are very busy, as are the founders and the judges.

    Thanks for taking such an interest in the blog.

    Happy Sniffing!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Wonderful! Thank you so much, Jeff! I am only at level 2, but many of the holes in my training come from not watching enough dog/handler teams work out problems, search area patterns, etc. I volunteer every chance I get at trials, but that is very limited. I became a member of the "30 second club" just last weekend in an interior search. I am quite bruised from kicking myself, but that is a lesson learned. I am sure I will do it again, but maybe I will at least think twice....

    Debbie and Kobie

    ReplyDelete
  18. Well said all around. Welcome to the club! Keep getting "scraped & bruised", it shows you're out there working hard to be the best handler you can be for your dog. Just remember to always have fun and make sure your dog is having fun with you as the team grows together and gets better and better.

    Happy Sniffing!

    ReplyDelete
  19. Jeff,

    What a wealth of information you have for beginners and advanced trainers.

    I feel your expertise is greatly appreciated!

    I would like to share that I am one of the essential oil suppliers for NACSW. Please feel free to contact us with any questions.

    We are excited to be a part of this great service.

    Thank You

    Chalyce Macoskey

    Essential7
    http://www.essential7.com/store/page12.html


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Chalyce!

      I hope the sport of K9 Nose Work and the NACSW have helped to bring you lots of new business, not only for the essential oils we use in competition, but for some blends to calm trial nerves, and to soothe us after a long hard day of competition.

      Thanks for checking out the blog and commenting.

      Happy Sniffing!

      Delete